CELA urges stronger source water protections in First Nations clean water bill

0
First Nations
CELA wants the bill's goal of "closing" gaps between First Nations and non-Indigenous communities in infrastructure, socio-economic status, governance, health and well-being strengthened to call for the "elimination" of those gaps. Pictured is a Haida Boat on the shoreline of Haida Gwaii, B.C. Credit: Colin, stock.adobe.com

The Canadian Environmental Law Association (CELA) is calling for several amendments to the proposed First Nations Clean Water Act to strengthen source water protection, while urging Parliament to move quickly to adopt the long-awaited legislation.

In its September 2026 analysis of Bill C-37, CELA said the legislation contains important provisions recognizing First Nations jurisdiction over water and incorporating source water protection into a multi-barrier approach to drinking water safety. However, the environmental law organization argues several sections should be clarified or strengthened before the bill becomes law.

Bill C-37 was introduced in the House of Commons on June 16, 2026, replacing the previous Bill C-61, which died when Parliament was prorogued in January 2025. The legislation would establish minimum national standards for water services on First Nation lands, affirm First Nations’ jurisdiction over water and source water, and create mechanisms for collaboration with other governments to protect water sources beyond First Nation lands.

CELA particularly supports provisions identifying source water protection as necessary for reliable access to clean and safe drinking water, as well as the bill’s adoption of a multi-barrier approach that includes source protection, treatment, monitoring, operator training and risk management.

Subscribe to our Newsletter!

The latest environmental engineering news direct to your inbox. You can unsubscribe at any time.

The organization said lessons from inquiries into the Walkerton and North Battleford water contamination crises demonstrated that protecting drinking water requires multiple “lines of defence” and that treatment and monitoring alone may not address every threat to drinking water.

One of CELA’s most significant proposed changes involves how the bill addresses source water located outside First Nation lands. Section 6 would affirm First Nations’ jurisdiction over water and source water within a protection zone “adjacent” to First Nation lands where the First Nation, federal government and relevant provincial or territorial government agree on how their respective laws will apply.

CELA wants the word “adjacent” removed, arguing that contaminants threatening a First Nation’s drinking water may originate considerably farther away. Surface water can be contaminated by activities upstream beyond immediately neighbouring properties, while groundwater supplying drinking water wells can be affected by contaminants entering an aquifer from more distant locations, the organization noted.

CELA recommends instead that the legislation refer to water and source water within a protection zone established “for” a First Nation.

At the same time, CELA supports the bill’s proposed use of coordination agreements between First Nations and federal, provincial or territorial governments. Such agreements could allow different jurisdictions to coordinate their laws, permits and enforcement activities to address threats to drinking water sources outside First Nation lands.

CELA pointed to Ontario’s source water protection framework as an example. Source protection plans can require municipalities to change permitted land uses or adopt bylaws restricting activities such as chemical storage near vulnerable aquifers.

Similar agreements involving First Nations could address federally regulated activities such as transportation of hazardous goods or provincially regulated pollution permits when those activities threaten a First Nation’s drinking water source, CELA said.

The organization also recommends strengthening the bill’s purpose provisions. Section 4 currently calls for collaboration through transboundary source water protection planning and agreements. CELA wants the provision to specify protection of drinking water sources accessed by First Nations communities through water surface intakes or wells.

Another proposed amendment concerns the legislation’s recognition of a human right to safe drinking water. Bill C-37 currently states that it is federal policy to “further the progressive realization” of that right for individuals on First Nation lands. CELA recommends replacing that language with a more explicit recognition that every individual on First Nation lands has a human right to access clean and safe drinking water.

CELA also wants the bill’s goal of “closing” gaps between First Nations and non-Indigenous communities in infrastructure, socio-economic status, governance, health and well-being strengthened to call for the “elimination” of those gaps.

Other recommendations include retaining provisions allowing First Nations to adopt innovative water technologies, preserving requirements related to transparency and free, prior and informed consent, and ensuring First Nations representatives are closely involved when federal, provincial and territorial drinking water standards are developed.

CELA also raised concerns about wording related to water quantity. Section 15 states that the quantity of water available “on” First Nation lands must be sufficient to meet drinking, cooking, sanitation, hygiene, safety, fire protection and emergency management needs, while accounting for cultural, spiritual and projected water needs.

The organization said that wording could create ambiguity because water used by a First Nation may originate from a nearby or more distant source. It recommends referring instead to the quantity of water “available to supply the needs” of First Nation members.

Despite its proposed amendments, CELA is urging Parliament to proceed quickly with the legislation following consultation and study. The organization noted that Bill C-61, the predecessor to Bill C-37, had already undergone extensive parliamentary committee study before dying on the order paper. CELA recommends that both the House of Commons and Senate study and adopt Bill C-37 on an expedited basis.

The federal government has similarly said Bill C-37 builds on years of consultation, engagement and parliamentary work on Bill C-61, including 18 committee meetings in 2024 involving 94 witnesses. The government says continued First Nations participation in the parliamentary process will be important in determining the legislation’s final form and implementation.

No posts to display

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here